IMF总裁格奥尔基耶娃:债务高企加大央行抗通胀难度
IMF Chief Kristalina Georgieva Talks US Economy, Kevin Warsh | Bloomberg Talks
Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio, news.
彭博音频工作室,播客、广播、新闻。
I'm here with the IMF managing director, Cristina Gorgva. After a momentous speech from Fed Chair Kevin Walsh, this is your first Jackson Hole summit. I would love to just first say thank you for joining us. What was your takeaway from Kevin W's speech. What did you think of it?
我在这里与IMF总裁克里斯蒂娜·戈尔格瓦在一起。在美联储主席凯文·沃尔什发表重要演讲之后,这是你首次参加杰克逊霍尔峰会。首先,我想感谢你接受我们的采访。你对凯文·沃尔什的演讲有何感想?你觉得怎么样?
He did a great job. He articulated his views on the evolution of monetary policy in a rapidly changing world very clearly and his commitment to price stability that 2% is a target for the Fed to achieve was very clear. Uh I think the uh audience was positively impressed by the clarity and also the message he communicated to the central bank king community. We have to be humble. The world is changing so rapidly. We have to carefully watch what is going on and make our best call for the benefits of people for the benefits of the economy.
他做得非常出色。他清晰地阐述了自己对快速变化世界中货币政策演变的看法,并且明确承诺价格稳定,即2%是美联储要实现的目标。我认为,听众对他的清晰表述以及他向央行行长群体传达的信息留下了积极印象。我们必须保持谦逊。世界变化如此之快,我们必须仔细观察正在发生的事情,并为人民和经济利益做出最佳决策。
You know you wrote you actually had also a speech uh later in the morning where you wrote central bank's most critical role is to ensure inflation remains low and stable. How do you understand the past five more than 5 years where inflation has been above target? Is this the fault of central bankers? Is this something else that we can address? What has happened over the last years is shock upon shock upon shock and that pressed governments to borrow and spend more than they should and of course that has some inflationary uh impact.
你知道,你后来在上午也发表了一篇演讲,其中你写道,央行最关键的角色是确保通胀保持低位且稳定。你如何理解过去五年多来通胀高于目标的情况?这是央行官员的错吗?还是我们可以解决的其他问题?过去几年发生的事情是接二连三的冲击,这迫使政府借贷和支出超出应有水平,当然这会产生一些通胀影响。
Uh and also we know that u when we were hit by COVID at that time the public spending was perhaps a bit more generous. Uh but how do you know how much is enough when the world economy comes to a screeching uh stop? I would blame central banks only if they don't draw lessons from experience and what we are seeing here in Jackson Hall and what we heard from uh chair wares they are drawing lessons from experience and the lesson at least on its face seems to be perhaps they need to be a bit more restrictive in their policies.
而且我们知道,当我们遭遇COVID时,当时的公共支出可能有点过于慷慨。但是,当世界经济突然停滞时,你怎么知道多少才算足够?我只会责怪那些不从经验中吸取教训的央行,而我们在杰克逊霍尔这里看到的以及我们从沃尔什主席那里听到的,他们正在从经验中吸取教训,至少表面上的教训似乎是,他们可能需要在其政策上更加严格一些。
Do you think that more broadly around the world that needs to be the approach even though shocks are still going to keep coming? It seems like the shock after shock after shock isn't really changing.
你认为在全球更广泛的范围内,即使冲击仍会不断到来,这种方法是否也需要被采纳?看起来接二连三的冲击并没有真正改变什么。
We have to accept this reality that the world is changing very rapidly and that part of this change is a positive or a negative shock. Right now we are dealing with two shocks that work in the in opposite directions. We have the energy supply shock and then we have AI. One drags grow down, the other one pushes it up. We have to get accustomed to an environment that is less predictable. What do you do in that environment when first build your buffers especially in good times?
我们必须接受这个现实,即世界正在飞速变化,而这种变化的一部分是正面或负面的冲击。目前我们正应对两股方向相反的冲击:能源供应冲击和人工智能。一个拖累增长,另一个推动增长。我们必须适应一个更不可预测的环境。在这种环境中,你该怎么办?首先,尤其是在好时期,要建立缓冲。
Right now the economy is doing well. Well, let's cut the deficit, bring down the debt. Uh, and two, recognize that your best friend are sound policies and strong institutions.
目前经济表现良好。那么,让我们削减赤字,降低债务。第二,要认识到你最好的朋友是稳健的政策和强大的制度。
Do you ever get frustrated? Do you feel like you're beating your head against the wall when you say come on get your house in order to people who are saying no thanks maybe the next guy can come around to do it because it seems like no one's listening
您是否曾感到沮丧?当您对那些说“不了,谢谢,也许下一位能搞定”的人说“请整顿好你们的财政”时,是否觉得像是在对牛弹琴,因为似乎没人听?
some are listening look at emerging markets they have done fabulously well the monetary policy frameworks are strong fiscal frameworks are much better sometimes we look at them they do better than advanced economy so some people that have had the painful experience of crisis is are listening. Uh it is human nature. When do we fix our roofs? When the sun is shining or when there is rain. So we will continue to shout police.
有些人在听。看看新兴市场,它们表现得非常出色。货币政策框架稳健,财政框架也好得多。有时我们看到它们比发达经济体做得更好。所以,那些经历过危机痛苦的人正在倾听。这是人之常情。我们什么时候修屋顶?是阳光明媚时还是下雨时?所以我们会继续大声疾呼。
The sun is shining. It's a good time. Bring the roofers. Bring the roofers. Ked Rogoff uh earlier a Harvard professor was talking with my colleague Tom Keane and he said ultimately it's going to take a debt crisis to really cause developed markets to get their fiscal house in order. Do you agree?
阳光明媚,正是好时机。把修屋顶的人叫来,把修屋顶的人叫来。肯·罗格夫,之前哈佛的一位教授,与我的同事汤姆·基恩交谈时说,最终需要一场债务危机才能真正让发达市场整顿好财政。您同意吗?
Not necessarily. We have seen historically that actions has been have been taken in good economic times. sound growth, good household spending, investments booming and then adjustments, fiscal adjustments uh take place. But we have to recognize that we live in a world of popular desire for the government to spend more. Why? Because the government has done it over the last couple of crisis. did it after COVID did it after the energy shock from the war in Ukraine and food shock price shock at that time.
不一定。历史上我们看到,在经济良好时期也曾采取过行动。增长稳健、家庭支出良好、投资繁荣,然后进行调整,财政调整得以实施。但我们必须认识到,我们生活在一个民众渴望政府增加支出的世界。为什么?因为政府在过去的几次危机中都是这么做的。在新冠疫情后做了,在乌克兰战争引发的能源冲击以及当时的食品和价格冲击后也做了。
So people are saying hey you did it continue not affordable. My message to everybody is delay no longer. Why? Because debt levels are now above where they were after the second world war. Uh, and Ken Roof is right to say, "Do you really want a crisis to get you to do what is necessary? Please act on your own."
所以人们说:“嘿,你做了,继续做吧,这负担不起。”我要对所有人传达的信息是:不要再拖延了。为什么?因为债务水平现在已经高于二战后的水平。肯·罗格夫说得对:“你真的想靠一场危机来迫使你做必要的事吗?请主动行动吧。”
It sounds like a kid who's gotten candy after everything that they've done and suddenly someone's saying, "Take the candy away. You might get a tantrum, but it is what it is." You wrote, you said in your speech also that IMF popularly stands for intern, it's mostly fiscal. It's an interesting point at a monetary policy conference. How has the fiscal debt overhang complicated monetary policy and made it a lot more difficult for policy makers to really address inflation just head on?
这听起来就像一个孩子在做完所有事情后得到了糖果,突然有人对他说:“把糖果拿走。”他可能会发脾气,但事实就是如此。你在演讲中也写道,IMF 常被戏称为“实习生”,主要是财政方面的。在货币政策会议上提出这一点很有趣。财政债务积压是如何使货币政策复杂化,并使政策制定者更难直接应对通胀的?
Well, first, more demand, more spending pushes price levels up, not down. Second, when we have a high level of debt, it is much harder for central banks to act decisively by raising interest rates. Why? Because then the cost of serving the debt is going to go up and they especially the Fed here dual mandate, price stability and employment. We don't want to undermine the strong performance of the economy and that is why their job is is harder.
首先,更多的需求和支出会推高价格水平,而不是降低。其次,当债务水平高企时,中央银行更难通过加息来果断行动。为什么?因为那样做会提高偿债成本,尤其是美联储,它有双重使命:价格稳定和就业。我们不想削弱经济的强劲表现,这就是为什么他们的工作更加困难。
But it is their job. They have first and foremost the responsibility for price stability.
但这是他们的职责。他们首要的责任是维护价格稳定。
Another aspect of this conference has been stable coin. Although if you get people in the hallways, no one wants to talk about stable coin. They're like, we're here to talk about something else. And it is not the question of exactly how we're gonna have digital assets. That said, you made a really interesting point about the role that technology plays in financial stability and how it could actually expedite or hasten crises stemming from monetary policy accidents or other or fiscal policy accidents.
这次会议的另一个方面是稳定币。尽管如果你在走廊里遇到人,没人愿意谈论稳定币。他们会说,我们来这里是为了讨论其他事情。而且问题不在于我们究竟如何拥有数字资产。尽管如此,你提出了一个非常有趣的观点,关于技术在金融稳定中的作用,以及它如何可能加速或加剧由货币政策失误或其他财政政策失误引发的危机。
Can you talk a little about that?
你能详细谈谈这一点吗?
Well, what we know is that financial innovation is good, but it increases risks. It accelerates impact and if this impact is possible positive, great. If it is negative, it can lead to spillover impacts within an economy and even across its borders. My message on this point is don't live with the illusion that technology is going to make your life simpler. It won't. You need strong policy frameworks. Even more so in a world of fast impact from technology.
我们知道的是,金融创新是好的,但它增加了风险。它加速了影响,如果这种影响是积极的,那很好。如果是消极的,它可能导致经济内部甚至跨境的溢出效应。我对此的观点是,不要幻想技术会让你的生活更简单。它不会。你需要强大的政策框架,尤其是在技术影响迅速的世界里更是如此。
More, not less.
更多,而不是更少。
I'm smiling because I don't think anyone feels like artificial intelligence has really made their lives that much more easier. Everyone's just trying to scramble to keep up with everything. Do you think right now that the potential issue that could cause some sort of systemic event really is inflation and potentially inflation getting a bit out of control and forcing the hand of central banks more aggressively. So the good news is that um um inflation expectations are still well anchored.
我微笑是因为我觉得没有人真正觉得人工智能让生活变得轻松了多少。每个人都在拼命追赶一切。你认为目前可能导致某种系统性事件的潜在问题真的是通货膨胀,且通胀可能有点失控,从而迫使各国央行更激进地采取行动吗?好消息是,通胀预期仍然被牢牢锚定。
We have had stubborn inflation and it is something that central banks ought to pay attention to and take action if necessary and it was very reassuring to hear Chair Walsh saying that if necessary we act. But we are not seeing the underlying trend to be one that creates fears that inflation is getting completely out of uh whack. It is not happening. Why is it important to act decisively early? Because if inflation expectations were to deank anchor then what would happen in markets is of course nervousness turning into panic.
我们确实遇到了顽固的通胀,这是央行应该关注并在必要时采取行动的事情,听到沃尔什主席表示如有必要我们会采取行动,这让人非常安心。但我们并未看到潜在趋势会引发通胀完全失控的担忧。这种情况并未发生。为什么尽早果断行动很重要?因为如果通胀预期脱锚,那么市场上会发生什么,当然是紧张情绪转变为恐慌。
We don't want that to happen. Do you think that there is a credibility issue for central banks in developed markets right now given the concerns with the fiscal overhang and given some of the fears that they've been reluctant to address inflation? Just trying to explain it away, trying to figure out wh
我们不希望这种情况发生。考虑到财政负担过重的担忧以及一些对央行不愿解决通胀问题的顾虑,你认为发达市场央行目前是否存在信誉问题?只是试图将其解释过去,试图弄清楚为什
原文超出正文长度上限,此处截断——上游还有内容,完整版见上方「原文 ↗」。
更进一步:量化金融体系
看懂新闻只是起点——沿量化金融路径,把它变成能交付的工程能力