Coin Metrics:代币化美股溢价与流动性缺口研究
Stock Market that Never Sleeps: Inside the Premiums and Liquidity Gaps of Tokenized Equities
提供代币化美股全市场数据与量化结论,揭示跨时区定价规律与套利摩擦,适合关注链上资产定价效率的研究者参考。
Get the best data-driven crypto insights and analysis every week:
每周获取最佳的数据驱动型加密货币洞察与分析:
Stock Market that Never Sleeps: Inside the Premiums and Liquidity Gaps of Tokenized Equities
永不眠息的股市:代币化股票的溢价与流动性缺口内幕
By: Cooper Duschang, Research Associate
作者:Cooper Duschang,研究助理
Thanks for reading Coin Metrics State of the Network! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
感谢阅读 Coin Metrics 网络状况报告!免费订阅以接收新文章并支持我的工作。
Key Takeaways:
关键要点:
- The total market cap of tokenized equities has grown to over $3B. Investors can gain on-chain exposure to stock prices through various issuers including xStocks, Ondo Tokenized Stocks, and bStocks.
- NVDAx traded above the NVDA price in 58.6% of market-open hours, averaging 3.1 bps in those hours; NVDAon did so in 88.9%, averaging 14.1 bps.
- Tokenized stock prices also vary by market and trade size. One tokenized stock on a specific market might have the lowest slippage on a $10K trade but not $100K. This requires cross-venue data to compare both slippage and tokenized stock coverage.
- 代币化股票的总市值已增长至超过 30 亿美元。投资者可以通过包括 xStocks、Ondo Tokenized Stocks 和 bStocks 在内的各种发行商,获得股票价格的链上敞口。
- NVDAx 在 58.6% 的交易时段内价格高于 NVDA,在这些时段平均高出 3.1 个基点;NVDAon 在 88.9% 的时段内价格更高,平均高出 14.1 个基点。
- 代币化股票的价格也因市场和交易规模而异。特定市场上的一只代币化股票可能在 1 万美元的交易中滑点最低,但在 10 万美元的交易中并非如此。这需要跨平台数据来比较滑点和代币化股票覆盖范围。
Introduction
引言
Between October 27 and November 2, exchanges have generated over $2B in volume on tokenized spot equity markets. As demand for on-chain exposure grows, custodians acquiring and issuing more tokenized stocks has led to the total market cap of tokenized equities jumping to over $3B.
在 10 月 27 日至 11 月 2 日期间,交易所产生的代币化现货股票市场交易量超过 20 亿美元。随着对链上敞口需求的增加,托管机构收购并发行更多代币化股票,推动代币化股票的总市值跃升至超过 30 亿美元。
Source: Talos CM Network Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Network Data Pro
While the market cap of tokenized stocks has grown steadily to ~$3B, spot trading volumes remain small relative to their perpetual counterparts. Over the past week, equity perpetuals on Hyperliquid generated roughly $12.3B in volume or 6x the $2.0B traded across tokenized-equity spot markets.
虽然代币化股票的市值稳步增长至约 30 亿美元,但其现货交易量相对于永续合约而言仍然很小。在过去一周,Hyperliquid 上的股票永续合约产生了约 123 亿美元的交易量,是代币化股票现货市场 20 亿美元交易量的 6 倍。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro
In this State of the Network we break down how tokenized stocks trade against the underlying stock, pricing during aftermarket and pre-market hours, and the market fragmentation of these assets.
在本期《网络状况》报告中,我们将深入解析代币化股票如何与基础股票进行交易、盘后和盘前时段的定价,以及这些资产的市场碎片化情况。
Tokenized Stocks v the Underlying Stock
代币化股票 vs 基础股票
Tokenized stocks are generally offered to non-U.S. investors and provide on-chain price exposure to U.S. equities, including outside U.S. market hours. Tokenized stocks are issued by entities that hold the underlying shares, typically through a custodian. Tokenized stocks trade in markets that operate 24/7, enabling continuous pricing when the underlying assets on traditional markets are closed.
代币化股票通常向非美国投资者提供,并为美国股票(包括美国市场休市期间)提供链上价格敞口。代币化股票由持有基础股份的实体发行,通常通过托管机构进行。代币化股票在 24/7 运营的市场上交易,使得在传统市场关闭的基础资产能够持续定价。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro, Yahoo Finance
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro, Yahoo Finance
Select users are whitelisted to mint new tokens and redeem for the underlying stock. This creates redemption risk for holders who do not have the same privilege. From October 27 through November 2, NVDAx, issued by xStocks, traded at an average premium of 3.1 bps during 58.6% of open market hours. NVDAon, issued by Ondo Stocks, traded at an average 14.1 bps premium during 88.9% of open market hours. Tokenized NVDA traded below Friday’s close, alongside a broader sell-off.
选定的用户被白名单收录,可以铸造新代币并兑换为底层股票。这为不具备同等特权的持有者带来了赎回风险。从10月27日至11月2日,由xStocks发行的NVDAx在58.6%的交易时段内以平均3.1个基点的溢价交易。由Ondo Stocks发行的NVDAon在88.9%的交易时段内以平均14.1个基点的溢价交易。代币化NVDA的价格低于周五收盘价,且伴随更广泛的市场抛售。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro
Exchange fragmentation has led to the same tokenized stock having different prices both during market open and closed hours across markets. Kraken’s NVDAx market averaged -0.9 bps versus NVDA during market-open hours.
交易所碎片化导致同一代币化股票在不同市场、不同时段(包括开盘和休市期间)出现不同的价格。Kraken的NVDAx市场在交易时段内的平均价格较NVDA低0.9个基点。
Using a lead-lag analysis, we compared NVDAx price moves while U.S. equity markets are closed against NVDA’s actual move into the next open. We measured three windows over 210 trading sessions (Jan 2026–present):
通过领先-滞后分析,我们比较了在美国股市休市期间NVDAx的价格变动与NVDA实际进入下一个交易时段的真实变动。我们在210个交易时段(2026年1月至今)中测量了三个窗口期:
- After-hours (4:00pm–8:00pm ET): evening token moves are only weakly related to where NVDA opens the next morning with a correlation coefficient of 0.24. Shortly after the close, the token carries little signal about the next day’s direction.
- Overnight (8:00pm-4:00am ET): overnight hours are weakly correlated with NVDA open price the following morning with a correlation coefficient of 0.3. This is stronger than the after-hours session and growing into the U.S. pre-market session.
- Pre-market (4:00am–9:29am ET): NVDAx steadily converges toward NVDA’s eventual open, reaching an R-squared of 0.42.
- Full overnight (4:00pm–9:30am ET): across the entire closed period the token tracks the stock almost perfectly with an R-squared of 0.98. By the open, NVDAx has fully met the underlying price, as expected.
- 盘后时段(美东时间下午4:00–晚上8:00):晚间代币价格变动与NVDA次日开盘价的关联度较弱,相关系数为0.24。收盘后不久,该代币对次日走势的信号指示作用微弱。
- 隔夜时段(美东时间晚上8:00–凌晨4:00):隔夜时段与次日早晨NVDA开盘价的相关性较弱,相关系数为0.3。这一相关性比盘后时段更强,并随着美国盘前交易时段的临近而增强。
- 盘前时段(美东时间凌晨4:00–上午9:29):NVDAx稳步收敛至NVDA的最终开盘价,决定系数(R-squared)达到0.42。
- 完整隔夜时段(美东时间下午4:00–上午9:30):在整个休市期间,代币几乎完美地追踪股票走势,决定系数高达0.98。到开盘时,正如预期那样,NVDAx已完全贴合底层资产价格。
The tokenized price and the real stock are tightly linked at the open, but that convergence builds through the pre-market hours. The after-hours session alone says little about the next day’s move.
代币化价格与实际股票在开盘时紧密挂钩,但这种收敛是通过盘前时段逐步建立的。仅凭盘后时段的数据很难预测次日的走势。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro, Yahoo Finance
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro,Yahoo Finance
Tokenized stocks are sensitive to price movements, specifically during closed market hours. When closed, Bybit and MEXC NVDAx markets have on average 19% less liquidity within 1% of the midprice. Hyperliquid shed roughly 33% of its depth within 1% of the midpoint when markets closed. Buying and selling during these liquidity shocks can further misprice the same NVDAx token across markets until the market reopens.
代币化股票对价格波动敏感,特别是在休市期间。休市时,Bybit和MEXC的NVDAx市场在中价1%范围内的流动性平均减少了19%。当市场休市时,Hyperliquid在中价1%范围内的深度流失了约33%。在这些流动性冲击期间进行买卖,可能会进一步导致同一NVDAx代币在不同市场中定价失真,直到市场重新开放。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro
When Do Tokenized Stocks Typically Trade?
代币化股票通常在何时交易?
Tokenized stocks can provide access to prices of underlying U.S. stocks to non-U.S. investors. Examining when tokenized stocks trade during the day could show whether even in less liquid markets during closed hours, investors continue to trade tokenized stocks.
代币化股票可以为非美国投资者提供获取美国底层股票价格的机会。考察代币化股票在一天中的交易时段,可以显示即使在休市期间流动性较低的市场中,投资者是否仍在继续交易代币化股票。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro
NVDA xStocks trade primarily around the market open and close. Between 9am and 10amET during weekdays, NVDAx averaged $225K in volume. Some trading occurs before and after market hours both in anticipation of the opening price and news occurring after. This does not clearly highlight which geographic region is trading these on exchanges. Offshore exchanges supporting these markets suggest international users are trading tokenized assets but primarily during U.S hours.
NVDA xStocks 主要在开盘和收盘时段交易。在工作日的上午 9 点至 10 点(ET)之间,NVDAx 的平均成交量为 22.5 万美元。在开盘前和收盘后也会发生一些交易,这是为了预期开盘价格以及应对盘后发生的新闻。这并不能清楚地表明是哪个地理区域在交易所交易这些资产。支持这些市场的离岸交易所表明国际用户正在交易代币化资产,但主要是在美国交易时段内。
Cross-Venue Execution
跨平台执行
Prices for the same tokenized stock differ across venues, so the cost of acquiring exposure depends on where an order is executed.
同一代币化股票在不同交易平台的价格存在差异,因此获取敞口的成本取决于订单在何处执行。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro
At smaller sizes, more exchanges can support the execution. For trades of $1K from October 27 through November 2, Bybit and Hyperliquid were the venues with the lowest slippage 58% and 23% of the time respectively. On trades of $100K, Bybit or Hyperliquid is the best venue 98.2% of the time.
在较小规模下,更多的交易所可以支持执行。从 10 月 27 日到 11 月 2 日,对于 1000 美元的 trades,Bybit 和 Hyperliquid 是滑点最低的交易平台,分别有 58% 和 23% 的时间表现最佳。对于 10 万美元的 trades,Bybit 或 Hyperliquid 在 98.2% 的时间里是最佳交易平台。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro
Comparing tokenized variants shows execution costs also differ by issuer. From October 27 through November 2, NVDAb on Binance showed the lowest slippage among the tokenized NVDA variants for $10K orders in 96% of observations.
比较代币化变体显示,执行成本也因发行方而异。从 10 月 27 日到 11 月 2 日,在 96% 的观察案例中,Binance 上的 NVDAb 在 1 万美元订单的代币化 NVDA 变体中显示出最低的滑点。
Do Price Gaps Survive Trading Costs?
价格缺口能否抵消交易成本?
Although exchanges having different prices for different tokenized variants could create potential opportunities, liquidity and trading cost must be considered when trading. From June 2026 to November 2, the average spread and slippage outweighed the observed price gaps even at $1K, before fees.
虽然不同交易平台对不同代币化变体拥有不同的价格可能会创造潜在机会,但在交易时必须考虑流动性和交易成本。从 2026 年 6 月到 11 月 2 日,平均价差和滑点在扣除费用之前,甚至在 1000 美元的交易中,也超过了观察到的价格缺口。
Source: Talos CM Market Data Pro
来源:Talos CM Market Data Pro
Conclusion
结论
Tokenized equities provide 24/7 pricing for assets that trade during traditional market hours to non-U.S. investors. These tokenized assets currently primarily trade during market hours and experience liquidity shocks during closed hours. Collecting data on tokenized asset order book depth, slippage, and reference rates help compare execution costs across tokenized stocks and exchanges.
代币化股票为非美国投资者提供了在传统市场交易时段内的资产 24/7 定价。这些代币化资产目前主要在交易时段内交易,并在休市期间经历流动性冲击。收集关于代币化资产订单簿深度、滑点和参考率的数据,有助于比较不同代币化股票和交易平台之间的执行成本。
Subscribe and Past Issues
订阅与往期内容
Coin Metrics State of the Network is an unbiased, weekly view of the crypto market informed by our own network (on-chain) and market data.
Coin Metrics 网络状况报告是一份 unbiased(无偏见)的每周加密货币市场概览,基于我们自身的网络(链上)和市场数据。
If you’d like to get State of the Network in your inbox, please subscribe here. You can see previous issues of State of the Network here.
如果您希望将《网络状态》(State of the Network)发送至您的邮箱,请在此订阅。您可以在此查看往期《网络状态》内容。
更进一步:量化金融体系
看懂新闻只是起点——沿量化金融路径,把它变成能交付的工程能力