预测市场监管推演:若最高法院拒绝审查Kalshi案的影响
Prediction Markets at the US Supreme Court 'What If:' What Happens If the Supreme Court Passes on Reviews?
本文提供了关于预测市场核心法律争议(对赌vs互换)及CFTC应对策略的系统性推演,为关注加密衍生品合规的从业者提供了可复用的监管逻辑参考。
The "multiverse" is an easy, quick "fix" that media companies have long used to get people to consume new media in popular fiction franchises without having to stick to the established "rules" of the franchise.
"多元宇宙"是媒体公司长期以来使用的一种简单、快速的“补救”手段,旨在促使人们在流行虚构作品系列中消费新内容,而无需拘泥于该系列既定的“规则”。
The goal is to milk a franchise cow until it resembles a hollow husk of its former glory, so pesky concerns like congruity and character arcs are acceptable casualties.
其目的是将一部系列作品榨干,使其沦为昔日辉煌的空壳,因此诸如连贯性和角色弧线等令人头疼的问题被视为可接受的牺牲品。
This article series takes that concept into an antecedent and non-fiction framework. This first iteration considers what might happen if the U.S. Supreme Court opts not to weigh in on the legal questions in Kalshi v. Assad, Kalshi v. Flaherty, and other cases.
本系列文章将该概念置于先例和非虚构框架中进行探讨。本次首次迭代考虑的是,如果美国最高法院选择不介入 Kalshi v. Assad、Kalshi v. Flaherty 及其他案件中的法律问题,可能会发生什么情况。
This piece is purely speculative and not intended to be a comprehensive look at all the possible ramifications of that action.
本文纯属推测,并非旨在全面审视该行动可能产生的所有影响。
Instead, it offers an overview of the most pertinent business and legal consequences. The discussion starts with establishing the premise, or why the Supreme Court might give Assad and Flaherty a miss.
相反,它提供了最相关的商业和法律后果的概述。讨论从确立前提开始,即为什么最高法院可能会回避对 Assad 和 Flaherty 案件的审理。
Why the Supreme Court might not review decisions in Assad and Flaherty
最高法院可能不会审查 Assad 和 Flaherty 案的判决
If an exchange were offering contracts on the Supreme Court granting cert on at least one of the current petitions in Assad or Flaherty, the "yes" side of that market should probably be trading between $0.65 and $0.70 right now.
如果某交易所正在提供关于最高法院批准至少一项当前在 Assad 或 Flaherty 案件中上诉申请的合约,那么该市场“是”这一侧的交易价格目前可能在 0.65 美元至 0.70 美元之间。
There are several factors pointing toward certification:
有几个因素指向批准受理(certiorari):
- The clean split between the US Third Circuit Court of Appeals and the Sixth/Ninth circuits on whether sports event contracts are gambling and whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling laws.
- Similar appeals are ongoing before the Second, Fourth, Seventh, and 10th circuits.
- The involvement of the US Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
- Both sides are asking for review.
- 美国第三巡回上诉法院与第六/第九巡回法院在体育事件合约是否构成赌博以及《商品交易法》是否优先于各州赌博法律问题上存在清晰的分歧。
- 类似的上诉正在第二、第四、第七和第十巡回法院进行。
- 美国司法部(DOJ)和商品期货交易委员会(CFTC)的参与
- 双方都要求复审。
However, the "no" side of that fictional market also merits consideration.
然而,该虚构市场中“否”的一侧也值得考虑。
Linda Goldstein, partner at CM Law, explains why: "The one thing that could stand in the way of cert is more procedural than substantive. All of the current rulings are preliminary-injunction rulings, not final merits judgments, and the CFTC has a pending rulemaking that could reshape the question.
CM Law 律师事务所合伙人 Linda Goldstein 解释了原因:“唯一可能阻碍批准受理的因素更多是程序性的而非实质性的。目前所有的裁决都是初步禁令裁决,而非最终实体判决,且 CFTC 有一项待进行的规则制定,可能会重塑这一问题。”
"The Justices sometimes prefer to wait for a final judgment or for the agency to finish acting. So if I had to predict, I would say it is likely the Supreme Court will grant cert, but I wouldn’t be shocked if the Court holds off for a term," Goldstein added.
"大法官们有时倾向于等待最终判决或等待机构完成行动。所以如果我必须预测,我会说最高法院很可能批准受理,但如果法院推迟一个任期再作决定,我也不会感到惊讶," Goldstein 补充道。
Assuming that the Supreme Court (SCOTUS) takes that path, many entities will have decisions to make. Among those is how prediction market operators will navigate a national landscape in which they must deal with differing legal precedents.
假设最高法院(SCOTUS)采取那条路径,许多实体将不得不做出决定。其中就包括预测市场运营商将如何应对这样一个全国性的局面:他们必须面对不同的法律先例。
The "patchwork" boogeyman for prediction market exchange operators
预测市场交易所运营商面临的“拼凑式”梦魇
Part of the argument that the CFTC/DOJ and exchange operators have made in court to date regarding the Commodity Exchange Act's (CEA) and the Dodd-Frank Act's potential preemption of state gambling laws is that Congress intended in those statutes to provide a uniform standard for financial markets throughout the country.
迄今为止,CFTC/DOJ 和交易所运营商在法庭上围绕《商品交易法》(CEA)和《多德-弗兰克法案》可能优先于州赌博法的论点中,有一部分是:国会旨在通过这些法规为全国金融市场提供统一的标准。
Some district courts have rightfully treated these "won't someone think of the children" pleas like a pampered pet cat crying about having to wait 10 seconds for its meals to be hand-delivered.
一些地区法院正确地对待了这些“难道没人想想孩子们吗”的呼吁,就像一只被宠坏的宠物猫抱怨它的饭菜要等10秒才能手递到手一样。
Somehow, gambling companies like DraftKings, Fanatics, and FanDuel barely eke out an existence with tens of billions of dollars in quarterly revenue while navigating jurisdictional disparities. Even people who bake brownies on the side manage varying regulations not just from state to state but within different parts of individual states without those disparities swallowing their enterprises whole.
不知何故,像 DraftKings、Fanatics 和 FanDuel 这样的赌博公司在季度收入达数百亿美元的情况下,勉强维持生存,同时应对司法管辖区的差异。即使是兼职烤布朗尼蛋糕的人,也能在不让差异吞噬整个企业的情况下,管理来自各州以及各州不同部分的多样化监管规定。
Goldstein also argues that a "patchwork" framework wouldn't be the specter from "The Ring" crawling out of the television for prediction market exchange operators.
Goldstein 还认为,“拼凑式”框架不会成为从《午夜凶铃》(The Ring)电视里爬出来的幽灵,困扰预测市场交易所运营商。
"The patchwork would be about how far state gambling law reaches, not about who regulates the exchanges themselves," Goldstein said. "The CFTC would still have exclusive jurisdiction over designated contract markets and trading on them. To be fair to the states, they would argue there is no patchwork of commodities law here because these contracts aren't swaps.
Goldstein 说:“问题在于州赌博法的适用范围有多广,而不是谁监管交易所本身。”“CFTC 仍将拥有对指定合约市场及其交易的专属管辖权。为了公平对待各州,他们会争辩说这里不存在商品法的‘拼凑’,因为这些合同不是互换合约。”
"They're sports bets, and gambling has always been regulated state by state," she continued. "That's really the core disagreement. The Third Circuit says they are swaps and the Ninth and Sixth Circuits say they are gambling. Even on the swap question, the Sixth Circuit made a pointed textual argument stating that because the CEA refers to event contracts that are 'unlawful under any Federal or State law,' the statute 'necessarily implies that certain event contracts may be listed in some states but not in others.' On that reading, arguably some state-by-state variation isn’t something Congress tried to stamp out. It’s something the statute expects. So while a denial would create a patchwork, there would still be disagreement on whether that is inconsistent with Congress’ intent."
"它们是体育博彩,而赌博一直由各州分别监管,"她继续说道。"这确实是核心分歧所在。第三巡回上诉法院认为它们属于互换合约,而第九和第六巡回上诉法院则认为它们属于赌博。即便在互换合约的问题上,第六巡回上诉法院也提出了一个明确的文本论证,指出由于《商品交易法》(CEA)提及的‘在任何联邦或州法律下均非法’的事件合约,该法规‘必然意味着某些事件合约可能在部分州被允许上市,而在其他州则不被允许’。按照这种解读,可以说各州之间的差异并非国会试图消除的内容,而是法规所预期的结果。因此,虽然驳回上诉会导致局面碎片化,但对于这是否与国会的意图相悖,仍存在争议。"
Another consideration is how the CFTC might proceed without SCOTUS guidance on these issues.
另一个考量因素是,在没有最高法院(SCOTUS)对这些问题提供指导的情况下,美国商品期货交易委员会(CFTC)将如何推进工作。
How the CFTC might move forward in the short-term
CFTC 在短期内可能采取的进展措施
Silence from SCOTUS on Assad and Kalshi would be tantamount to consent to the Third and Ninth Circuit rulings in those cases, even if only temporarily. The result would be a new status quo for the CFTC Chair Michael Selig regardless.
最高法院对 Assad 案和 Kalshi 案保持沉默,等同于暂时认可了这两个案件中第三和第九巡回上诉法院的裁决。无论情况如何,这将导致 CFTC 主席迈克尔·塞利格(Michael Selig)面临一种新的现状。
In the short term, Selig would have two considerations for how he moves forward. Those are what to do in other outstanding lawsuits and how to proceed in rulemaking.
在短期内,塞利格在决定后续行动时将考虑两个方面:如何处理其他未决诉讼,以及如何推进规则制定工作。
On litigation, Goldstein does not expect Selig to pull up stakes.
在诉讼方面,戈德斯坦(Goldstein)不认为塞利格会撤出战场。
"Under Chairman Selig, the agency has been very clear that it sees itself as the sole regulator here," Goldstein said. "What I’d expect is a more selective approach. Where a circuit hasn’t yet issued binding adverse precedent, like the Second or Fourth, the CFTC would likely keep pressing, since a favorable ruling there deepens the split and keeps the issue alive. In circuits where it has already lost, it might voluntarily dismiss or seek stays rather than produce more bad law."
"在塞利格主席领导下,该机构非常明确地表明,它视自己为唯一的监管机构,"戈德斯坦说。"我预计采取的方法会更加具有选择性。对于那些尚未发布具有约束力的不利先例的巡回法院,如第二或第四巡回法院,CFTC 可能会继续施压,因为有利于他们的判决会加深分歧并使该问题持续存在。在已经败诉的巡回法院辖区,它可能会选择自愿撤诉或寻求中止程序,而不是制造更多对其不利的判例。"
Goldstein also believes that Selig might shift more of his attention and time to regulatory powers.
戈德斯坦还认为,塞利格可能会将更多的注意力和时间转移到监管权力上。
"After Loper Bright, courts no longer defer to an agency’s reading of the statute, but a carefully reasoned notice-and-comment rule can still be persuasive, and it builds a better record," Goldstein added. "[Those actions could include] finalizing the Rule 40.11 amendments and Appendix F. The proposal defines 'gaming' fairly narrowly as activities for recreation or entertainment, governed by rules, where outcomes turn on luck, skill, or athletic ability during the activity. It also takes the preliminary view that the agency won’t make categorical public-interest determinations, and it gives exchanges procedural rights. Second, further rules defining event contracts as swaps, which goes right to the issue that split the circuits. Third, a formal interpretive statement laying out the agency’s preemption view, even though courts won’t defer to it."
Goldstein 补充道:"在 Loper Bright 案之后,法院不再对机构对法规的解释给予尊重,但经过审慎推理的通告与评论规则仍具有说服力,并且能构建更完善的记录。[这些行动可能包括]最终确定第 40.11 条修正案和附录 F。该提案将'博弈'相当狭窄地定义为以娱乐或消遣为目的的活动,受规则约束,且结果取决于活动过程中的运气、技巧或运动能力。它还初步认为,该机构不会做出类别性的公共利益认定,并赋予交易所程序性权利。其次,进一步制定规则,将事件合约定义为互换合约,这直接触及了导致各巡回法院分歧的问题。第三,发布一份正式的阐释性声明,阐明机构的优先权观点,尽管法院不会对此给予尊重。"
"The agency may also try to take some of the steam out of state objections by tightening core-principle requirements for exchanges on market integrity, geofencing, and age verification," Goldstein continued. "Those are the consumer-protection concerns states keep raising. Memoranda of understanding with willing states and staff advisories are other possibilities."
Goldstein 继续说道:"该机构也可能试图通过收紧对交易所在市场诚信、地理围栏技术和年龄验证方面的核心原则要求,来削弱各州的反对声浪。"这些都是各州不断提出的消费者保护关切。与愿意合作的州签订谅解备忘录以及发布员工咨询意见是其他可能性。"
From a longer-term perspective, more unknown quantities enter the chat.
从更长远的角度来看,更多未知因素进入讨论。
Questions arise for CFTC with long-term prognostications
长期预测引发针对商品期货交易委员会(CFTC)的疑问
The future of prediction market regulation becomes murkier in terms of the CFTC's role and how it might shape the activity long term without guidance from SCOTUS. That's partly because the agency's future depends on political fortunes.
由于缺乏最高法院(SCOTUS)的指导,预测市场监管的未来在 CFTC 的角色及其长期可能如何塑造该活动方面变得愈发模糊。部分原因在于,该机构的未来取决于政治运势。
更进一步:量化金融体系
看懂新闻只是起点——沿量化金融路径,把它变成能交付的工程能力